Your CFO says find carbon accounting software. You've got a shared drive full of untouched utility bills, a reporting deadline, and a page of Google results where every vendor ranks itself first. We build software too, so we're biased. But this is the checklist we'd hand a colleague before they evaluate anything, us included.
Start with the documents, not the dashboard
The hard part of carbon accounting isn't the maths. Multiplying kilowatt-hours by a factor is arithmetic. The hard part is getting the kilowatt-hours out of a scanned PDF whose layout changes every time your retailer redesigns the bill. Ask any vendor, on the demo: can I upload a scanned fuel docket, a multi-page electricity bill and a supplier invoice, and get calculations without typing anything in? If the honest answer is "export it to our CSV template first," that's a spreadsheet with a login. Test it with your own worst document, not their tidy sample. (Here's what that looks like in ours.)
NGER-native or bolted on?
Australian compliance has specifics a global platform tends to treat as a regional add-on. NGER needs per-facility tracking and the NGA Factors DCCEEW publishes annually, which differ by state. Victoria's grid factor is several times Tasmania's, so a national average can misstate a facility's electricity emissions substantially. NGER uses AR5 global warming potentials; AASB S2 uses AR6. A platform that doesn't handle both leaves you maintaining parallel calculations. Ask which edition of NGA Factors it runs today, and how quickly it updates when a new one drops.
AASB S2 is four pillars, not one number
Mandatory climate reporting isn't only Scope 1 and 2 arithmetic. It spans governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets. Most calculators do the metrics pillar well and leave you a blank Word document for the other three. Nobody automates governance disclosure, and you shouldn't trust a vendor who claims to. But the platform should at least give you the structure, the prompts and the evidence trail. Ask: can it structure disclosures for all four pillars, or only metrics? If only metrics, you'll need a second system for the rest, which defeats the point.
What about just using a general-purpose AI?
A fair question in 2026: why not paste your bills into a general-purpose AI and ask for the emissions? For exploring a figure, drafting a narrative or getting a rough sense of scale, that genuinely works, and it's a legitimate way to start. The gap shows up when the number has to be defensible.
Exploring the number
Reading a messy PDF, drafting a narrative, sizing a figure. Modern models do this well, and it's a fine place to start.
Signing your name under it
A general model can't reliably say which NGA Factors edition it used, whether it applied AR5 or AR6, or link each figure to its source, and may answer the same question two ways.
For a disclosure an assurer will test, you need the factor current and named, the working reproducible, and every figure traceable to its source. None of this is anti-AI, quite the opposite: explore the number however you like, then bring it somewhere that makes it defensible. The strongest platforms go further and let your AI assistant connect to them directly, so the answer comes back grounded in the current factors with the sources cited, not guessed.
The five questions to take into every demo
Before you sign
- Can it read my actual documents, messy formats and all, with no manual entry?
- Which edition of NGA Factors is it on, and how fast does it update?
- Does it handle both AR5 and AR6 GWP values without parallel workbooks?
- Does every figure trace back to its source document and factor for assurance?
- Is pricing a predictable subscription, and what's the cost per reporting cycle?
“If it can't handle what your suppliers actually send you, the feature list doesn't matter.”
The one test that decides itTest it with your own documents
Bring the messy bills and invoices you actually have. Our AI Sustainability Analyst reads them, calculates against current factors, and shows the source behind every figure.
Book a Sustainability Check-up